Welcome to La Pizza Italia
La Pizza Italia is a hidden gem located at 959 2nd Ave, New York, NY, renowned for its authentic New York-style pizzas. Each pie, including favorites like the Chicken Parm Pie and Pepperoni Pizza, boasts a perfect balance of thin crust, fresh ingredients, and rich flavors. Patrons rave about the inviting atmosphere and exemplary service. The staff's warmth enhances the dining experience, making guests feel like valued friends. With signature offerings that reflect culinary passion, La Pizza Italia promises a memorable pizza experience that keeps visitors returning for more deliciousness and camaraderie.
-
959 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States959 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States Hotline: +1 917-965-2248
Welcome to La Pizza Italia, a gem nestled in the heart of Manhattan, at 959 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022. This vibrant pizzeria is not just about serving up delicious slices; it's about crafting an experience that resonates with every pizza lover. When you step inside, you’re greeted not only by the mouth-watering aroma of fresh ingredients but also by a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes you feel instantly at home.
La Pizza Italia offers a diverse selection of pizzas that cater to every palate, but it is their signature Honey Vodka Pizza that truly stands out. Each bite reveals a perfect blend of homemade vodka sauce, creamy fresh mozzarella, and a drizzle of signature hot honey that elevates this culinary creation to new heights. The Pepperoni Pizza and the White with Garlic Pizza are also noteworthy, featuring a thin, crispy crust paired with the finest mozzarella and quality toppings, providing an authentic taste of New York-style pizza.
Customer reviews echo the sentiments of many; La Pizza Italia is described as a "wonderful pizza place" with “incredible” service. Patrons frequently mention the friendliness of the staff who treat you like family and go out of their way to ensure a positive dining experience. Whether you are stopping in for a quick slice or enjoying a leisurely meal with friends, the vibrant atmosphere combined with the soulful, comforting food makes each visit memorable.
As you enjoy your meal, don’t be surprised if the music sets a lively tone, enhancing the overall vibe of the place. With their commitment to quality and a deep passion for pizza, La Pizza Italia earns its place among the city’s best. Don't miss out on this delicious haven; it's a must-visit for anyone craving a delicious slice in New York City. Come for the pizza, stay for the experience!
This place was amazing and their food was incredible. They serve some really good pizza here, it was some of the best I've had here in Manhattan. I would highly recommend this place, the atmosphere is nice and everyone working there looked to be having a great time. Everyone was super friendly and the service was quick. They also gave us 2 garlic breads on the house for our order.
Such a wonderful pizza place. I was traveling with 3 of my friends and we stopped by. Wonderful service and great atmosphere. I mean the pizzarrrr? DELISH! The guy who helped us choose which slices we wanted was so sweet. The music was such a vibe as well. Definitely recommend if you are in the area and looking for something quick and tasty.
This is our first trip back to NYC in a while, and pizza was our first lunch option. La Pizza Italia did not disappoint! The crust was textbook perfect, ample toppings, and just enough cheese and olive oil to balance out every bite. The staff were super-friendly, and the constant foot traffic was a testament to this location's popularity. Excellent pizza!!!
Rating: 5/5 This is one of those pizzerias where you want to come back again and again – not only because of the tasty food, but also because of the incredibly polite and friendly staff. The team is super kind and welcoming – from the first moment you feel like a valued guest. Everything is done with a smile and great care. The pizza is amazing: thin crust, fresh ingredients, and a smell that makes your mouth water. Be sure to try their signature options – you can feel that they cook with love. The atmosphere is very cozy, perfect for a dinner for two or a meeting with friends. Thank you to the whole team for the great service and positive vibes – we will definitely be back!
A great place if you’re craving a NY-style slice of pizza. Delicious and very friendly service. I tried the burrata basil and buffalo chicken slices, both were excellent. Highly recommended!
Good pizza, Raphael was very attentive and helpful, his customer service skills are outstanding. His service was commendable and the highlight of this venue. About the food; the pizza slices are humongous, I struggled to finish mine. I recommend the Vodka slice, it was yummy. The burrata and basil pizza slice was okay, but it wasn’t something for me therefore I can’t recommend it. UPDATE 31/05/2025: I have changed my mind about the Burrata pizza slice, it was good. Make sure you have it when it’s warm, rather than eating it cold.
“4.8 google review, how good that could be?” That’s my question before I stepped into the store. After first bite of the Burrata Basil, I rate it 5/5. Not just because of the great topping, but also the perfect pizza dough, no rind wasted!
This place was by my hotel so I decided to stop in and I’m glad I did. The pizza slice was huge and had plenty of topping. The crust was crispy and the sauce was really good, kinda sweet. I’ve never had anything like it but it was delicious. The guy taking my order was a friendly guy too.